Protesters don’t understand the plan – Fish and Game

Hundreds of protesters on tractors rolled into a small town in Hawke's Bay today to object to proposed water conservation orders. About 300 tractors rolled into the small town of Clive on Tuesday afternoon. It follows an application by groups including the Fish & Game council and Whitewater New Zealand to place water conservation orders on two of the region's largest rivers, the Ngaruroro and Clive. Orders were first sought in 2009 but Fish & Game said they would not affect existing resource consents and protesters had failed to understand the intent. Fish & Game New Zealand chief executive Bryce Johnson said critics had not bothered to read the proposals and he would be happy to meet the groups and explain. Water conservation orders, which fall under the Resource Management Act, are designed to recognise and protect the outstanding values of particular bodies of water. Some people said they feared the orders could have serious effects on the region's rural sector, but Fish & Game accused protesters of ignorance. Jerf van Beek, who chairs a growers' cooperative, said it was disappointing conservation orders were sought. He said the region only used 2 percent of its allowable water allocation and that included use for primary production. "Without the water we cannot produce what we're so well known for - the high quality produce that we can get high value for. "[That means] we can pay our staff well and we can make more investment so more tamariki, more young people, can actually come and join us in our industry. We now have to say this is actually really shaky ground." Mr van Beek said the turnout of urban Hawke's Bay residents showed it was not only the rural sector which would be affected if restrictions were introduced. "They couldn't actually irrigate their sports parks. In Hawke's Bay it gets really dry. One [year] in three it gets really, really dry. It would mean we would have no water, we couldn't play sport because it would be unsafe. "These things just cannot happen and that's why we're so angry and why the community is right here now supporting us." Waiora Tareha, a solo mother supporting a 5-year-old daughter, works at the Bostock Orchard. She said she was very concerned about what would happen if water conservation orders were put in place. "The worst thing would be that they'd have to stop all production entirely, so that would be shut down all their businesses because we all doubt that they would be able to grow and manage enough crops to export overseas to make enough money." However, Fish & Game New Zealand chief executive Bryce Johnson said the water conservation orders were first sought in 2009 and he believed locals were ignorant about what was involved, including that the orders would not affect existing resource consents for water. "That's explicitly stated in the statute and I just don't think critics have bothered to read that. "We would be more than happy to meet with these groups and talk them through the legislation, explain what our aspirations are for this and how it won't really affect their existing takes." The Environmental Protection Authority said a hearing for the water conservation order applications may take place before the end of the year. So far, conservation orders have been granted for 15 rivers and lakes.

Comment & Analysis

‘Slow slip’ earthquakes explained

New research shows November's 7.8 magnitude Kaikōura earthquake sparked a series of unprecedented 'slow slip events' off the east coast of the North Island, up to 600km away. Here is how this recently discovered phenomenon works and why it matters. How is a slow slip different to a normal earthquake? Slow slip events (also known as 'slow earthquakes') are similar to earthquakes that we feel, but are quite different at the same time. They are similar because they involve more rapid than normal movement between two pieces of the Earth's crust along a fault. But, unlike regular earthquakes, where the movement occurs in seconds, movement during slow slip events can take weeks to months to occur. The release of energy and ground movement is incredibly slow so we don't feel them at the surface like we do during earthquakes - but GPS-enabled instruments that monitor tiny, millimetre-level changes in ground movement do. Where do they happen? Slow slip events, like other earthquakes, are often observed at 'subduction zone' tectonic plate boundaries. Subduction zones are where two tectonic plates meet and one of the plates dives down beneath the plate next to it. We have two subduction zones in New Zealand: the Puysegur subduction zone south of the South Island, where the Australian Plate dives below the Pacific Plate; and the Hikurangi subduction system off the east coast of the North Island, where the opposite is going on and the Pacific Plate dives under the Australian Plate. In the middle, the two plates move past each other laterally, and we have the Alpine Fault. How do they happen? Where the two plates meet at depth beneath the Earth is where it gets interesting. In some places, the plates move freely past each other, but in other places, the plates can become locked together due to friction on the fault between them. This builds up tension, and when it's released the movement can be fast (causing an earthquake) or slow (like what happens during a slow slip event). Slow slips are common at the Hikurangi subduction zone. In fact, they were first observed there - under the seafloor just east of Gisborne - back in 2002. Since then, New Zealand scientists have observed dozens of these events on the plate boundary beneath the North Island. Should we be worried? For the most part, slow slip events help to relieve built-up tectonic stress, instead of this stress being relieved by large earthquakes. So, they are a good thing - we should be very happy that they happen! However, when a slow slip occurs, it can redistribute that stress to other parts of the plate boundary. In New Zealand, we often see swarms of small earthquakes during slow slips, which is part of that process of redistributing the tectonic stress. It is possible that some slow slips could trigger larger earthquakes, but that is probably extremely rare indeed. Scientists are currently trying to better understand the relationships between slow slips and earthquakes so that in the future we may be able to use them to improve earthquake forecasting. How did the Kaikōura quake trigger the North Island east coast slow slip? The Kaikōura earthquake triggered a large slow slip event along much of the Hikurangi subduction zone (which is more than 600km away from the earthquake epicentre). As the seismic energy from the quake moved north, it temporarily added more stress to the subduction zone, triggering the event. The illustration at the top of this page shows the passing seismic waves - in red lines - at the plate boundary east of the North Island. The event has been described - by GNS Science's Laura Wallace - as the "largest and most widespread episode of slow slip observed in New Zealand ... this is probably the clearest example documented worldwide of long distance, large-scale slow slip triggering". It was detected by GeoNet's continuously operating GPS network. It occurred less than 15km deep below the surface (or seabed) and spanned more than 15,000 sq km offshore from the Hawke's Bay and Gisborne regions, and took just two to three weeks to occur. Slow slip movement was also triggered beneath the Kāpiti Coast region - at deeper levels, about 30-50km beneath the Earth's surface, on the boundary between the Pacific and Australian Plates. Slippage of up to 0.5m was also observed beneath the Marlborough region. The slip occurring between Kāpiti and Marlborough is still going on today, but has slowed significantly and is now happening at a rate of about 1cm a month. What's new about this week's research? New research into the Hawke's Bay and Gisborne slow slip event suggests the shallow part (less than 15km deep) of subduction plate boundaries may be more susceptible to the triggering of slow slips by passing seismic waves from distant earthquakes. This is because of the sedimentary wedge that typically overlies the shallow part of most boundaries. This wedge traps and amplifies seismic waves. This can cause large changes in stress on the boundary fault, which are capable of triggering slow slips. The study published this week in Nature Geoscience took advantage of the entire range of data provided by GeoNet. It features new models of seismic wave movement as well as using GPS to detect slow slips. The researchers used GeoNet's strong motion seismic data from around the whole country and compared this with computer-generated seismograms, which were created using the New Zealand supercomputer known as NeSI. We are now closer to understanding more about the relationship between earthquakes and slow slips. What's next? The scientists are currently working on research papers to explain the deeper Kāpiti and Marlborough events that followed the Kaikōura earthquake. Source: Adapted from this blog post on GeoNet's website with help from GNS Science geophysicist Laura Wallace, who co-authored the recent research with GNS Science seismologist Yoshihira Kaneko and others.


Thanks, you're good to go!

Thanks, you're good to go!

{{ contentNotIncluded('company') }} has not subscribed to {{ contentNotIncluded('contentType') }}.

Ask your librarian to subscribe to this service next year. Alternatively, use a home network and buy a digital subscription—just $1/week...

Go back


Subscribe to our free newsletter for news and prizes